「光り輝く」学びの多い合同例会 - Joint Meeting with Takatsuki TMC

今回は初めて高槻TMCとの合同例会でした。コロナ禍においてオンラインミーティングが強いられる中、このように地域的な制約なしに東京と大阪のクラブがつながり合同例会が開催できることは、良い面での副産物ですね。

両クラブの例会の進め方について知り合う良い機会ともなりました。

まず、高槻のＹさんによる「寄り添う論評」についてのワークショップ。スピーチする者に対する論評者として意義のある存在になれるようなTipsが多数含まれ、改めて、スピーチ者、論評者、総合論評者の役割について考えさせられ、成長を促せるコメントの必要性を痛感させられる示唆に富む内容でした。

また、各スピーチに対して、調布では各スピーチ者に対して通常１者で論評を行うところ、２者で論評を行ったことにより、スピーチ者にとって、複数の有意なコメントが得られたことを期待します。

加えて、テーブルトピックは梅雨やコロナ禍にちなんだタイムリーなトピックで、時勢を考えさせられるものでした。

最後に、論評のワークショップをしてくださった高槻のYさんによる総合論評。ワークショップの内容を踏まえた、褒めるだけでない、改善の観点からのコメントが踏まえられており、総合論評の「実践」として非常に参考になりました。

今日の言葉「Radiant」につながる、正に「光り輝く」学びの多い例会でした！！！

This was the first joint meeting with Takatsuki TMC. It is a good by-product that clubs in Tokyo and Osaka can be connected and a joint meeting can be held without regional restrictions while online meetings are being forced due to COVID-19 pandemic.

It was also a good opportunity to get to know how to proceed with the regular meetings of both clubs.

First, a workshop about “General Evaluation by getting close to speakers” was held by Mr. Y of Takatsuki. It contains lots of tips that will make us meaningful as an evaluator for the speaker, and furthermore makes us think about the roles of the speaker, evaluator, and general evaluator. We were keenly aware of the need for comments that can promote growth. The content was totally thought-provoking.

Then, for each speech, in Chofu, each speaker is usually commented by one person. However, this time, speakers were commented by two evaluators. We expect that speakers were able to get multiple significant comments.

In addition, the table topic was a timely topic associated with the rainy season and the COVID-19, which made us think about the times.

Finally, a general evaluation was done by Mr. Y of Takatsuki who gave the related workshop at the beginning. Based on the contents of the workshop, comments from the viewpoint of improvement, not just praise, were taken into consideration, which was helpful as a “practice” of the general evaluation.

The meeting became fruitful with lots of learning that was truly “shining” that led to today’s word “Radiant”!